Tuesday, June 21, 2011

The Ethics of Permaculture

The Ethical Principles of Permaculture

Any philosophy has its own set of principles or ethics whether they are written or not.  Permaculture is no different.  When Bill Mollison and David Holmgren developed the formal ideas of Permaculture, they also developed three guiding ethical principles.

Permaculture Ethics
1. Earth Care
2. People Care
3. Fair Share

Now first, let me point out that these principles are all EQUAL in value; one is not more important than the other.  There are consequences to generally treating the Earth as more important than Humans, and there are consequences to generally treating Humans as more important than the Earth.  There are many ways to interpret these ethical principles, and this is my attempt, my version, my interpretation.  I do not hold these as scripture, because Permaculture is not my religion.  But it is a marvelous tool.

Earth Care
The Garden of Eden, Jan the Elder Brueghel - 1612
I am immediately reminded of what the Bible says in Genesis 2:15: The LORD God took the man and put him in the Garden of Eden to work it and take care of it (emphasis mine).

I think there are a lot of people who have forgotten one of mankind's first duties.  Take care of the Earth.  Understand that our life is sustained by what we have on this planet.  Air, water, soil, and all forms of life are interconnected.  Whether you call it the Butterfly Effect or Chaos Theory, a person's actions will have a consequence or domino effect on every other part of the whole system... the Earth.  I don't mean this in a spiritual way.  I mean it as scientific fact.  If we cut down the rainforest, we lose species of plant and animal for ever.  Was there a new cure for cancer in one of those plants we just lost?  Did we just destroy yet another one of God's amazing species in our mismanagement of the forest?

A parasite is a creature that slowly sucks up all the resources from its host while giving nothing in return.  When people treat the Earth with no regard for the future, then we are no better than planetary parasites.  I am truly not an eco-fanatic, but I am an ecologist (defined: a biologist who studies the relationship between an organism and its environment).  I have a biology and medical degree, and I have a keen interest in the relationship between our environment our health.  I have seen that when people care for the environment, they are caring for themselves.

Which leads me to the next ethical principle...

People Care
Do Unto Others, Norman Rockwell - 1961
I am very interested in Wilderness Medicine.  One of the first things I was taught when dealing with a wilderness emergency is to assess scene safety, whether it is an avalanche, flood, or landslide.  Only when I know the scene is safe do I enter and help others.  This is not selfish.  If anything it is the opposite.  If I heroically give my life to save another person, and I am the only one with medical knowledge in the disaster area, then dozens more people may die because I am not there to help them.  I have to survive to help others.  This is also true of my family and my community.  I need to care for myself so that I may continue to care for others.

When we put our focus on caring for ourself so that we can care for others (as opposed to caring for ourself as the final goal), our whole attitude shifts.  We start to think more about our family.  We also begin to think about the children in our life and their children's children.  We think more about the actions we are taking today that may effect them and their future.  This ties into how we use our land, the chemicals we choose not to use, the trees we plant that will live for hundreds of years after we are gone... ultimately then this ties right back to the first principle: Earth Care.

Finally, our mind starts to focus on  neighbors and community and ways we can help to build it.  As Jesus said in Matthew 7:12: So in everything, do to others what you would have them do to you.  We start to reach out and help others that are less fortunate or who are lacking the information that we have.  We begin to teach others to take care of themselves.  When we give a man a fish, we feel good about ourselves for doing something nice, but this is an example of caring for ourselves as the final goal, not others.  When we teach a man to fish, we are now truly helping him.  If we teach him how to raise fish and then he sells them, we are now helping the whole community.

And this leads me to the third ethical principle...

Fair Share
The Four Elements - Earth, Joachim Beuckelaer - 1569
This is often interpreted to be some form of socialism, and I think this is why there are many neo-hippy communes that crop up around Permaculture centers.  In my opinion, Permaculture is not about giving away everything you worked so hard for to others that did not work.  This is one trap of human nature: expecting others to do your work for you.  And it is wrong.

Here is another trap of human nature: preventing others from caring for themselves and their families and communities so that you can accumulate beyond your ability to use.  And this also is wrong.

What this principle is talking about in my opinion (and according to Bill Mollison) is about setting limits to your consumption.  If you produce excess, then store it away for yourself or your children to use later, or sell it or trade it to those that want it so you can have other things that you need or desire.  But do not limit the ability of another person to do the same.  And do not take too much from the Earth that it has to recover and cannot provide for your children and their children.

The only ethical decision is to take responsibility for our own existence and that of our children.
- Bill Mollison

And that is it.  Earth Care.  People Care.  Fair Share.

It is that simple.  When we are managing our land in a way that is sustainable (Earth Care) and producing for our family and community (People Care) in a way that allows and encourages others to do the same (Fair Share), then we are practicing Permaculture.



  2. Very nice summation and interpretation of the basic tenants of permaculture. Working smarter, WITH nature for a better harvest, life, world. Permaculture = the thinking man's/person's agriculture.

    1. I like that. The "thinking man's agriculture."

  3. Thinking has to be balanced with intuition. Neo-hippies have their place else permaculture becomes just another ego play thing of those in the know complaining of those who don't.

  4. Thanks for clarifying the 3rd ethic, socialism is a corrosive rot that in the end kills communities and societies. It would be wonderful if there was a general awakening to the enduring truth of this ethic, AND have governments of the world be held to it also. Our "leadrs" are currently selling off our children's futures with unpayable debt. Local, as in your own back yard, Permaculture that provides food and builds community is the bright answer to a lot of today's problems. Thanks for your efforts, they are greatly appreciated.

    1. Capitalism does the same, Hello? Detroit, Pollution, etc. Any system whose only concept of moving forward is growth at any and all expense is going to falter. Until we change the system toward sustainability and resilience, we are going to be fighting for the last scraps of a decaying civilization and biosphere.

      It's so easy to pick an ideology, sit back and sling blame at another, when in reality, we are all at fault for playing into the consumer paradigm.

  5. Did you know you can shorten your long urls with Shortest and earn $$$ from every visit to your shortened links.